Skip to content
← Latent

Industry/

What the Christmas AI row was actually about

Dior disclosed late and lost a week. McDonald's disclosed everything and still got pulled. What five brands' Christmas advertising actually proves about AI.

Two Christmases ago Coca-Cola put the first fully AI‑generated film on broadcast and got hammered for it. Last Christmas McDonald’s pulled one after four days. This year Prada drew every frame by hand, Levi’s shot four hours of film for every second of animation, Coca-Cola quietly hired a camera crew again, and Dior spent a week explaining itself.

Five of the biggest advertisers in the world, one question, five different answers. We make films with AI, so we’re the last people you should take on trust here. Saying it anyway, because the obvious reading of all this is the wrong one.

Five brands, two years

Coca-Cola, 2024 and 2025. Two generative‑AI holiday films. Criticised both times. They never hid it, they led with it. Pratik Thakar, their global VP for generative AI, said the second one was “ten times better” than the first and that you “cannot keep everyone 100 percent happy”. This year’s Enjoy Joy is live action, shot by Paul Dektor through Mayan Productions, out of WPP Open X and Ogilvy. Nobody explained the change. They just stopped.

McDonald’s Netherlands, December 2025. It’s the Most Terrible Time of the Year went up on the 6th. Forty‑five seconds of AI‑generated people having a miserable holiday: a car off an overpass, a tree injury, carollers in a blizzard, one man blacking out the city. Andy Williams reworked underneath it. It ends on “hide out in McDonald’s till January’s here”. TBWA\Neboko made it with Sweetshop. Gone within days.

Prada, this month. Drawing Prada: Animated By Hand. John Pomeroy ran it, a man who animated at Disney for decades, and his team drew every frame. The characters sit inside live action Glen Luchford shot. Miuccia Prada and Raf Simons on creative direction, Ferdinando Verderi on the campaign. Sadie Sink, Maya Hawke, Chen Haoyu, Luther Ford and Kelvin Harrison Jr. are in it.

Levi’s, this month. Let’s Get Fuzzy. Sixty seconds of claymation about a yeti called Gus who can’t get into a cabin party until a red sweater fits him. Blinkink in London made it, directed by Stevie Gee and Essy May, who wrote fourteen scripts before Levi’s picked the yeti one. No agency at all. Levi’s hired the studio and gave notes straight to the directors. Six people, two thousand hours of set building, four hundred miniature trees, all painted by hand.

4hrs

of filming for every second of finished Levi’s animation. It isn’t a boast about effort. It’s a number anyone can check, and that turns out to be the useful bit.

Dior, 4 November. Christian Dior’s Night in Color. Sylvain Chomet directed, Robert Pattinson narrates, Rihanna and Josh O’Connor are in it. Chomet made The Triplets of Belleville. No shortage of craft in that room either.

Coca-Cola2024, 2025

Two generative‑AI holiday films, announced as such.

Told you up front

Criticised both years. Back to a camera in 2026, no explanation given.

McDonald’s NLDec 2025

Fully AI‑generated. Seven weeks, thousands of takes, agency proud of it.

Told you up front

Pulled within days. The method was never the problem. The idea was.

Dior4 Nov 2026

Hand‑drawn animation by Sylvain Chomet, plus automated interpolation.

Said after being asked

A week of explaining. Credits name the animators, not the software.

PradaNov 2026

Every frame by hand, inside live action. Animator and photographer named.

Told you up front

Praised. Nothing left for anyone to reveal.

Levi’sNov 2026

Stop‑motion claymation. Studio, directors, hours and trees all published.

Told you up front

Praised. The four‑hours‑per‑second figure travelled by itself.

The week Dior had

On 5 November an artist posting as NIRD listed what they read as AI tells. The 2D moved stiffly. Lettering warped. A lazy eye. A finger in the wrong place. Same day, Chomet told Business of Fashion the film was made “technically” the way it would have been in the 1940s, cut‑outs and characters animated separately.

Two days later he told Variety: “We used an automated interpolation system for a very small part of the process.” The end credits list the animators. They don’t mention that. Inc. asked Dior for comment. Dior didn’t reply.

Once a brand is explaining how its film was made, nobody is watching the film any more.

In Chomet’s defence

Automated interpolation isn’t generative AI, and that difference is real. Interpolation fills the frames between two drawings an animator already made. It’s inbetweening, as old as the industry, done by junior staff for a century before software took it over. Nothing gets invented. The drawings on either side are still somebody’s.

So a seventy‑year‑old technique, sped up, may well have been read as a machine writing the film. We weren’t in the room on any of these. Neither were the people who decided the case online.

Doesn’t help him. Dior might be completely right on the facts and it still lost the week. Being right stops being a defence the moment an audience starts hunting for seams, because by then they’re watching the method instead of the film.

Where the tidy version falls apart

Easy conclusion: tell people and you’ll be fine. McDonald’s kills that one.

They hid nothing. The agency briefed the production company to make the whole thing with AI and said so proudly. Sweetshop’s chief executive described seven weeks of work and thousands of takes: “This wasn’t an AI trick. It was a film.” A colleague put it harder: “AI didn’t make this film. We did.” Full disclosure, real labour, and it still came down.

The pipeline was never the issue. The film told families at Christmas that everything is awful and they should hide in a McDonald’s until January. Good luck selling that with any technology. The machine took the blame for a decision no machine made, which happens constantly and gets examined almost never.

What the five cases actually leave you

Disclosure doesn’t make a film good. It kills one failure and one only: the story where a brand gets caught having claimed something that wasn’t true. That one is expensive in a way the others aren’t, because it doesn’t end when the film does. It sticks to the brand.

Prada and Levi’s published everything. The animator’s name and his history. The studio. The directors. How many scripts. How many hours. How many trees. All of it checkable before anyone thought to ask, so there was nothing left to find. You can’t catch someone who already told you.

Dior made a beautiful film and mentioned the one thing that mattered only after someone else brought it up. McDonald’s told everyone everything and made a film nobody wanted. Coca-Cola did both over two years and has stopped answering the question.

What we take from it

In advertising the method is part of the product now. Not everywhere, not in every category. But once people are going frame by frame looking for evidence, you’ve lost already, whatever the evidence turns out to say.

Two things follow, not one. Put what made the film in the credits, the day it goes out, so there’s no reveal left for anyone. Then don’t expect that to rescue a film with nothing to say, because it won’t, and the machine will wear the blame on the idea’s behalf.

We publish our prices for the same reason we’d publish our method. A studio that tells you the cost before you ask is usually one that’ll tell you how it was made, and both answers get cheaper the earlier you give them.

Prada’s film is lovely. Levi’s is better than it needed to be. Ours is a different craft and we’re not going to borrow their warmth by pretending otherwise. The lesson we’re taking is smaller than the one the internet took, and more use: say how, then make sure the how was worth saying.

sillyhumans is an AI film studio in Singapore, making brand films and campaigns for brands internationally.

See the workStart a brief

Next — Industry Why brands are hiring AI film studios instead of production companies Read